Apart from Jensen Huang, these CEOs were also once ousted from their companies.
Jensen Huang is gone, yet employees and investors want him back.
As reported by Wired, a senior engineer at NVIDIA posted on the company's internal network, calling on the board of directors to listen to employees' opinions. The post has received more than 1,600 comments, most of which support Jensen Huang's return. One top comment reads: "If you believe in this company's mission, bring our boss back."
Some people have set up an independent petition website "Stand with Jensen". As of November 17, the number of signatories has exceeded 190,000. Website data shows that nearly 9,000 of them claim to be NVIDIA employees, and nearly 95,000 claim to be NVIDIA investors. Renowned entrepreneurs including Elon Musk, Garry Tan, CEO of Y Combinator, Tim Sweeney, CEO of Epic Games, and Amjad Masad, CEO of Replit have also joined the solidarity campaign.
Jensen Huang himself has not given up. As reported by the Financial Times, he is discussing the possibility of returning to NVIDIA with his close confidants, and his allies are forming a "war room" composed of Silicon Valley executives, lobbying the board of directors on one hand, and striving for support from the White House on the other. However, as of now, the board of directors has no intention of reappointing him.
At present, NVIDIA is led by former CFO Colette Kress as interim CEO, while the board of directors is selecting a permanent candidate. Names widely discussed by the public include Ian Buck, a NVIDIA executive involved in the early development of CUDA, and Rene Haas, CEO of Arm. Trump also publicly proposed on November 12 that Tim Cook, who just stepped down as Apple CEO, take over the position.
It is rare to see such a situation: a company in its prime growth period sees its founder suddenly leave, with employees and investors unanimously calling for his return, while the board of directors refuses to give in for a long time. But the "founder being ousted" scenario itself is nothing new in Silicon Valley.
A 2020 study by Harvard Law School examined 18,000 U.S. startups: among the companies that eventually went public, only 41% were still led by their founders as CEOs at the time of IPO; three years after IPO, this proportion dropped to 21%.
Founders who were ousted have vastly different endings. Steve Jobs returned to Apple 11 years after he left, and launched the iMac and iPhone; Sam Altman was removed by the OpenAI board, and returned to his position just a few days later; Jack Dorsey waited seven years at Twitter to get back the CEO position. However, Eberhard, the earliest CEO of Tesla, Kalanick, former CEO of Uber, and Neumann, former CEO of WeWork, never got their positions back.
What makes the difference? In these cases, some people gradually lost their equity and voting rights in successive financing rounds, some lost even with a large number of voting rights in hand, and some won with almost no shares at all. What really plays a role are several other factors: which side the board of directors stands on, who controls the capital, and who the core employees are willing to follow.
Let's start with the most well-known case.
Steve Jobs: Ousted by the CEO he personally hired
In 1985, the Macintosh, the personal computer that Apple placed high hopes on, sold poorly. Jobs advocated cutting prices, increasing advertising investment, and shifting the business focus from the still profitable Apple II to the Macintosh. Then-CEO John Sculley worried that price cuts and high marketing expenses would erode profits, and advocated continuing to make money through the Apple II to win more growth time for the Macintosh.
Ironically, Sculley was poached by Jobs himself from PepsiCo. Back then, to persuade him, Jobs threw out the widely circulated invitation later: "Do you want to sell sugar water for the rest of your life, or come with me to change the world?"
Business differences soon evolved into power struggles, and the contradiction was eventually brought to the board of directors for ruling. Most directors supported Sculley and authorized him to remove Jobs at the right time. On May 31, Sculley announced that Jobs was removed from his position as general manager of the Macintosh division. Jobs remained chairman, but no longer managed the actual business. More than three months later, on September 18, Jobs voluntarily resigned from his positions as chairman and director, and left Apple.
One of the reasons why Jobs could not stop all this was equity. As early as before Apple went public, his shareholding and voting rights had dropped to 15%, and he only had 9% left when he left. More critically, people who used to be on good terms with him in the board of directors also lost patience:
Mike Markkula was one of Apple's earliest investors and also served as Apple's CEO; Arthur Rock is a well-known Silicon Valley venture capitalist who once criticized Jobs' management style in person; Philip Schlein, described by the author of *Steve Jobs* as Jobs' most steadfast supporter on the board of directors, once persuaded him to step down from the daily operation of the Macintosh division.
At that time, the Macintosh team was in chaotic management, R&D was delayed, and Jobs kept interfering in other departments. After the conflict with Sculley broke out, he invited Markkula to his home to persuade him to change his stance, but was rejected.
11 years after Jobs left Apple, a turning point came at the end of 1996. Apple was in urgent need of a new operating system to replace the outdated Mac OS, and acquired NeXT, the company founded by Jobs after he left. Jobs returned as a consultant. In the following eight months, Gil Amelio, then CEO of Apple, gradually lost the support of the board of directors, while Jobs re-earned the trust of the management and the board. He promoted the CEO replacement, board restructuring and business reform, and took the position of interim CEO in September 1997.
The subsequent reforms were resolute: he cut non-core projects such as printers, laid off staff and cut costs, and reduced 15 computer products into three major product families. By the fourth quarter of 1997, Apple ended seven consecutive quarters of losses, and achieved a net profit of 309 million US dollars in the 1998 fiscal year.
Jobs' story shows that losing control does not mean being out, and opportunities can appear in unexpected ways a decade later. But not all founders get such a second chance.
Elon Musk: Ousted others, and was ousted three times
After Musk took control of Tesla through investment, he ousted the original CEO.
Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning founded Tesla in 2003, and Musk became the chairman through investment in 2004. At first they shared the same vision: to build high-performance pure electric sports cars. In May 2007, Musk even praised Eberhard in an email as one of the few outstanding product talents in the world.
But as the business advanced, differences emerged. Eberhard wanted to start mass production as soon as possible; Musk had higher requirements for appearance and performance, insisted on using more expensive carbon fiber bodies, and required redesigning the door sills, which pushed up R&D costs and time. In mid-2007, Tesla re-calculated the manufacturing cost of the Roadster and found that the average cost of the first 50 vehicles might exceed 100,000 US dollars, far higher than the previously estimated 65,000 US dollars, while the base selling price of the Roadster was only about 92,000 US dollars. The gearbox reliability problem was not solved for a long time, and Eberhard gradually lost the trust of the board of directors.
Even Laurie Yoler, a director who always appreciated his technical capabilities, began to question his management style. Co-founder Tarpenning also believed that when the company moved to the Roadster mass production stage, it needed a more experienced operator than Eberhard.
More importantly, the board of directors was dominated by Musk. In fact, until Tesla went public in 2010, Musk still held 35.61% of the equity; his brother Kimbal Musk was on the board of directors, as well as Antonio Gracias, founder of Valor Equity, who had a close personal friendship with him. Eberhard later claimed in the lawsuit that after the completion of the Series D financing in 2007, six of the seven directors were already under Musk's influence.
In July 2007, the two sides had a fierce conflict at the board meeting. As reported by *Fortune*, Musk and three other directors all believed at that time that Eberhard was no longer suitable to serve as CEO. Eberhard was forced to step down, and the board of directors brought in Michael Marks, former CEO of Flextronics, to take over. Eberhard initially remained as president of technology, but Musk wanted him to leave completely. In November 2008, under the pressure of the board of directors, he signed a separation agreement, receiving 100,000 US dollars in compensation, stock options and a seat on the advisory board as separation terms.
After that, Tesla changed two more CEOs, and Musk was never satisfied. In the 2008 financial crisis, Tesla was blocked in financing and fell into trouble again. Musk decided to step forward and officially take the position of CEO.
It is worth mentioning that Musk was ousted from the CEO position twice in his early days. In 1996, he and his brother Kimbal founded Zip2, an internet city guide platform. The venture capital institution Mohr Davidow Ventures believed that the company needed a more mature management team, replaced Musk, and brought in professional manager Rich Sorkin as CEO, while Musk retained the position of chairman.
The same thing happened again in 2000. X.com, the internet financial platform founded by Musk, merged with Confinity founded by Peter Thiel and Max Levchin, and Musk served as CEO. The two teams had serious differences in product concepts: Musk wanted to retain financial services, while Thiel and others believed that PayPal, the payment service launched by Confinity, had already achieved real user growth, and resources should be concentrated on it. In September 2000, while Musk and his first wife Justine Wilson were on their honeymoon in Australia, a group of executives threatened to resign, forcing the board of directors to remove him, and Thiel took over as CEO.
After taking charge of Tesla, he was almost removed again. In August 2018, Musk announced on Twitter that he was considering taking Tesla private at 420 US dollars per share, claiming that "funding has been secured". The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investigation found that he did not obtain definite financing commitments sufficient to support this statement, and sued him for securities fraud on September 27. The two sides reached a settlement soon after: Musk kept his CEO position, but had to step down as chairman for at least three years, and he and Tesla each paid a fine of 20 million US dollars.
OpenAI: Employees "suppressed" a coup
On November 17, 2023, the OpenAI board of directors removed Sam Altman, co-founder and CEO. Five days later, he resumed his position with the support of employees and Microsoft, the largest investor.
The trigger of the incident was his contradiction with Ilya Sutskever, co-founder and chief scientist, which was already an open secret inside the company. The core difference is how to treat model safety: Sutskever believes that AI is getting stronger and may gradually get out of human control, advocating strengthening safety research and review; Altman hopes to accelerate iteration and promote the rapid development and commercialization of OpenAI.
The differences gradually spread from the technical route to corporate management. Internal materials disclosed later show that executives including Sutskever believed that Altman provided inaccurate information many times, and even misled the management on whether some AI products passed the safety review. Director Helen Toner later gave a rather absurd example in an interview: when ChatGPT was launched in 2022, the board of directors only learned about it through Twitter.
On November 17, Sutskever, together with three other directors, removed Altman and expelled him from the board of directors. The reason why the board of directors had the right to remove Altman without going through Microsoft, the largest investor, comes from OpenAI's special governance structure. When it was founded in 2015, it was a non-profit organization for AI research, operating on donations from Musk, Peter Thiel and others, with a total announced fundraising commitment of 1 billion US dollars at the time of establishment. There were no shareholders in the traditional sense, and the highest power was in the hands of the non-profit board of directors.
As the demand for capital and computing power for AI research surged, donations could no longer sustain the operation. In 2017, OpenAI began to consider introducing a for-profit structure. Musk once tried to obtain majority equity, control and the CEO position through investment, but was opposed by Altman and others; he then proposed to merge OpenAI into Tesla, which was also rejected. In February 2018, the unprofitable Musk finally withdrew from the OpenAI board of directors.
In 2019, OpenAI established the limited partnership OpenAI LP for external financing, and introduced a profit cap mechanism at the same time: investors can share future profits, but excess returns belong to the non-profit organization. Microsoft has invested a total of 13 billion US dollars from 2019 to 2023, but the company's strategy and operation are still controlled by the non-profit organization, and Microsoft has no seat on the board of directors.
However, the members of OpenAI's board of directors obviously underestimated the power of capital. After the removal, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella first promoted Altman's return. When the negotiation failed, he announced that he would hire Altman, Brockman and their team, and provide the resources needed to continue AI R&D. The situation reversed instantly. On November 20, more than 700 employees (accounting for about 90% of the total number of employees at that time) jointly signed a letter demanding Altman's position be restored, otherwise they would consider leaving.
This removal was eventually "suppressed". The core figures who promoted the removal, including Sutskever, all signed the joint letter supporting Altman's return. On November 29, Altman resumed his position as CEO, the original board of directors was restructured, three of the four directors who promoted the removal left, and only Adam D'Angelo, founder of Quora, remained.
In the story of OpenAI, employees and capital parties joined forces to reverse a board coup within a few days. However, controlling the board of directors does not mean getting a free pass.
Uber: Controlled the board of directors, but was still forced to step down
Founders who cannot control the board of directors may lose power at any time, but controlling the board of directors does not mean having a free pass.
On June 20, 2017, Travis Kalanick, co-founder and CEO of Uber, resigned under the pressure of major investors. Five investment institutions including Benchmark jointly wrote a letter demanding that he hand over the CEO position immediately, on the grounds that successive exposed scandals had damaged the company's operation and reputation, and Uber needed a new leader.
A few months ago, a former engineer accused of being sexually harassed by her direct manager, and the company's management failed to properly handle it for a long time. Subsequent internal investigations found dozens of cases of sexual harassment, discrimination and workplace bullying. Kalanick himself was also full of controversies: in an interview, he jokingly called Uber "Boob-er" which has a meaning related to female breasts; he lost his temper and swore when arguing with Uber drivers about price cuts; he also wrote "dare to step on other people's toes" into the corporate values, a culture that was later criticized as condoning workplace bullying.
But it was not easy to make him leave. According to the complaint later submitted by Benchmark, Kalanick held about 10% of the shares at that time, owned about 16% of the voting rights, and had the right to appoint three directors. Co-founder Garrett Camp and early CEO Ryan Graves were all his supporters.
Benchmark's solution was to unite four other investment institutions, and the five parties together held about 40% of the voting rights. On the same day, Benchmark partners Matt Cohler and Peter Fenton flew to Chicago to meet him in person. Kalanick later stated in court documents that the two clearly told him: if he did not sign the resignation letter within a few hours, Benchmark would make a public attack. After several hours of negotiation, he agreed to resign.
At that time, Uber was already deep in a governance crisis: multiple executive positions including CFO and COO were vacant. Investors believed that as long as Kalanick and the negative public opinion around him remained, it would be difficult to recruit excellent new executives, and the upcoming IPO would also be affected. The company was also involved in a lawsuit with Google Waymo, accused of stealing autonomous driving trade secrets, and was exposed to use the Greyball tool to identify law enforcement officers and restrict their use of services.
Under multiple pressures, Kalanick accepted the demands of the shareholders. In 2019, he sold his shares, and stepped down from the board of directors at the end of the year, completely saying goodbye to the company he founded.
Kalanick lost to scandals and the investor alliance. The next founder is the opposite: he has enough voting rights to control the company, but lost to capital.