I just want to simply turn off my phone, why on earth do I have to go through such a complicated "combination punch" of operations?
Recently, when we chatted with colleagues, we talked about a trivial matter: it seems that it is getting harder and harder for current mobile phones to perform a normal "shutdown" operation.
In the earliest days, you only needed to long press the power button to turn off the phone. But ever since the "AI assistant" came out, the long-press operation on the power button has been set by default to call up the AI assistant. However, if you keep holding the power button "a little longer", the shutdown menu will still pop up.
But now, on many latest models, the phone can no longer be shut down no matter how long you hold the power button. Some models will pop up a prompt telling you that you must use the key combination of "Volume Up + Power Button" to call up the shutdown function. Others don't even give a prompt, forcing users to figure it out by themselves.
What's worse, some models that used to support "long press the power button to shut down" have changed the shutdown logic to require pressing the volume button and the power button at the same time after updating to the latest system, without notifying users at all.
Faced with our confusion, some colleagues looked both calm and puzzled. He said, "The combination key shutdown has existed for a long time, right? At least on iPhones, it has been this way for several years."
After being chided like this, we calmed down. After careful consideration, we began to realize that there seems to be more to this matter than meets the eye.
First of all, how problematic is the "combination key" shutdown
To be fair, for current smartphones, "shutdown" does seem to be an operation that is rarely used.
On the one hand, today's smartphones are all equipped with automatic maintenance mechanisms. Even if you don't turn off the phone for a long time, it will not become noticeably laggy. Coupled with the popularity of fast charging, almost everyone is used to "charging whenever needed", and few people still have the habit of turning off their phones before going to bed and charging them overnight.
But precisely because of this, for many people, when the time comes that "the phone must be shut down", it often means a more urgent situation that cannot be delayed.
For example, if your phone suddenly overheats severely or freezes for unknown reasons, quickly shutting it down is not only the first reaction of most people, but also the most direct way to save the device and even protect personal safety.
Another example: if the phone is infected with a virus or remotely controlled, when property security is threatened, shutting down is the simplest way to cut off the threat.
In addition, in some serious occasions (examination rooms, conference venues) where you have to hand in your phone, no one wants their phone to suddenly ring in the storage cabinet, so you will definitely turn it off immediately, right?
Of course, some friends may point out that now it often takes three or four seconds, or even more than ten seconds to respond when you long press the power button to shut down the phone, while the combination key only needs to be pressed for one second to pop up the shutdown interface, which is much faster, isn't it?
This statement is true, but the premise is that in such an emergency, you can still accurately press two different buttons at the same time. Not to mention the risk of misoperation or panicking, what about elderly users?
Then why do manufacturers force the promotion of combination key shutdown?
In fact, the answer to this question may not be complicated, there are only two reasons. The first is to change user habits to pave the way for future businesses; the second is the consistent lack of confidence among manufacturers in the Android camp.
Let's talk about changing user habits first. As we all know, today's smartphones generally take AI as a "selling point", but AI functions are currently free add-ons for users, which may not be the case in the future. For example, Samsung has been exposed that it may provide subscription paid services for AI functions of subsequent new phones. Some domestic brands are not far behind. Although their AI functions are not charged on the surface, the obvious "limited-time free" label is telling users that these functions may be paid in the future.
So how to get users to form the habit of using mobile AI functions, or even become dependent on them?
Make AI services better and more powerful? That's obviously the fundamental solution, but it requires huge investment. And at this stage, consumers have not developed the habit of "paying for AI", so the better manufacturers make their AI services, the more losses they will actually suffer.
In contrast, seizing the "power button" entry first and forcibly setting it as the shortcut for AI functions is naturally the lowest-cost and easiest way to cultivate user habits. After all, intentionally or unintentionally, as long as you press the power button and call up the AI assistant, you may become a "loyal user" of mobile AI services in the future.
As for the "lack of confidence" of Android camp manufacturers, we have to talk about the well-known brand Apple. Since the iPhone X in 2017, Apple has created the design of "long press the power button to call up Siri" and "use combination keys to shut down", which has been used for almost 10 years.
Over the past 10 years, it is obvious that as iPhones sell better and better, "learning from Apple" has increasingly become the consensus of manufacturers in the Android camp. From appearance design, linear motor vibration to button logic, "Apple-style design" is never a new thing. Even Google, the core leader of the Android ecosystem, has changed the shutdown method to "the same as iPhone" in the latest versions of the system.
Actually, no one will completely oppose AI assistants. After all, a smart new entry on the phone can really help many people solve problems. But technological progress should not block the way of old users. While building new fast lanes, it should also reserve an access for the "sidewalk". It is no problem to set AI as the default function of the power button, but the last fallback of "long press to bring up the shutdown menu" is technically completely easy to achieve. We only hope that manufacturers will not make the shutdown function of mobile phones as complicated as a treasure map, forcing users to learn a "combination of moves" just to turn off their phones.
The change of a single shutdown operation seems insignificant, but it reflects the growing desire of relevant manufacturers to dominate user experience: how you want to operate doesn't matter, what I want you to see is what matters. We hope that while mobile phone manufacturers are thinking about future businesses, they can occasionally look down and notice those users who are still looking for the shutdown button in the old way.
This article is from the WeChat Official Account "3eLife" (ID: IT-3eLife), written by 3eJun, and authorized for release by 36Kr.