Juewei's explosive popularity, Sam's Club seizing market share, Jinlimen accelerating financing: the fresh snack industry has kicked off a three-way fierce rivalry
Recently, Jinlimen, the leading fresh snack brand that has gone viral in major cities, has made new moves in capital operation.
According to Tianyancha APP, Shenzhen Warren Road Commercial Management Co., Ltd., the major shareholder of Hunan Explorer Brand Management Co., Ltd. (the operating entity of Jinlimen), has pledged 1.7985 million yuan of its equity to Xiamen HSG Xingrui Innovation Technology Co., Ltd., an affiliated party of HSG.
Equity pledge of non-listed companies, to put it bluntly, means mortgaging the equity to the other party in exchange for a sum of money or a commitment.
Neither party has disclosed the specific operation method so far.
However, one thing is certain, Jinlimen has entered an acceleration stage in terms of capital operation and store opening speed in recent months.
For example, in September, WU Yuening, founder of KK Group, and Guangdong Kuike E-commerce Co., Ltd., the operating entity of KK Group, entered the market at the same time, holding a total of 10% equity of Jinlimen; in October, the affiliated entity of Buer Capital took a 3.5% stake.
In terms of store opening, by mid-October, the number of directly-operated stores exceeded 50, and the number of new stores added in the 5 months from May to October was equivalent to the total number of stores opened by the brand in the past 5 years; about 20 new stores were added in the three months from July to October, marking a period of high-density store expansion.
It is definitely a good thing for capital to enter the market, especially in the current sluggish consumption situation, Jinlimen, as the leading brand, takes the lead in financing, making everyone expect that fresh snacks will become the second bulk snack, quickly spreading across the streets and alleys all over the country.
However, some different views hold that the business formats of fresh snacks and bulk snacks are different, and Jinlimen adopts a refined direct sales operation mode. If the acceleration driven by capital disrupts the original rhythm and the management cannot keep up, it may not be a good thing.
So what is the truth?
Capital rushes into the market, is Jinlimen "on the rise"?
Regarding the impact of capital entry, the market's concerns are indeed well-founded.
For example, Qian Dama, the leading community fresh food chain, was forced to continue expanding through franchising, which made franchisees complain constantly; another example is Wanchen Group, which is now eager to list on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. Its expansion speed is not slow, but there are always negative news about store operations from time to time...
However, from these cases, the premise of disrupting the rhythm is the coercion of the performance betting agreement and the pressure to generate further profits.
But Jinlimen does not have such worries now. First, public channels do not show that Jinlimen has signed a performance betting agreement. Second, the current founding team controls the enterprise with 40.1% equity, and the profit rhythm is relatively stable.
Therefore, at least for now, the addition of capital has not brought the so-called "trouble" to Jinlimen.
On the contrary, the KK faction that entered through the first round of financing may be empowering Jinlimen:
First, it brings Jinlimen high-quality location resources.
The KK faction that entered through the first round of strategic financing currently has accumulated operation experience of 1,380 retail stores and deep cooperative relationships with shopping malls.
And don't forget that almost all of Jinlimen's first stores are opened in MixC and Mixc World of the CR Land system. If the CR Land system really follows up with investment later, the shopping mall resources will be further increased.
This is crucial against the industry background where there are many new players and the whole track is accelerating store opening.
Second, it is the strong alliance in operation.
In terms of the output of chain retail middle platform and store operation capabilities, KK Group has many years of experience in large-format retail operation, and has precipitated a complete set of methodologies for store traffic line design, inventory turnover, loss control, store standardization, and young customer group operation.
Jinlimen's short-preservation fresh food has very high requirements for inventory and loss management, and its main customer groups are also mainly young people.
KK's set of experiences can be used to polish the store SOP, improve the single-store profit model, and build a cross-regional store management system, which is a perfect match for Jinlimen's demands.
Finally, it is brand synergy and capital endorsement.
On the one hand, there is room for synergy between the two sides in terms of product co-branding and passenger flow linkage; on the other hand, this industrial capital shareholding is a rare large-scale industrial investment in the fresh snack track, providing endorsement for subsequent connection with other commercial management entities, financing and capital market communication.
Buer Capital, which entered the market later, is itself a vertical fund focused on the consumer track, which can output experience in consumer brand governance, compliance construction and capital planning.
More critically, Jinlimen itself has performed well enough now, and almost every directly-operated store it opens becomes a hit.
For example, the first store in Nanjing MixC World achieved sales of over 300,000 yuan on its opening day, with a total of over 1 million yuan in the first three days; the first month sales of Hefei Luyang MixC store exceeded 6 million yuan.
The first provincial stores outside Hunan opened in Guangzhou, Foshan, Zhuhai, Shanghai and other places from September to October, generally had long queues during the opening period, and the Shanghai MixC store even temporarily restricted passenger flow due to overload.
Moreover, the popularity is not accidental, and its operation mode has strong replicability.
For example, the number of directly-operated stores exceeded 50 by mid-October, and almost all new stores follow the same operation model, mostly located in MixC series shopping malls, replicating a stable check-in effect across cities.
According to the survey data of securities firms and on-site tracking data, its operation capability is quite prominent in the current snack track. The average monthly sales of its brand's single store is about 1.5 million yuan, and the monthly sales of high-quality stores can reach more than 4 million yuan; the customer unit price is stable at 50-60 yuan, and the gross profit margin is 35%-40%, higher than the industry average.
As a short-preservation fresh food model, short-preservation SKUs with a shelf life of 1-5 days account for nearly half, contributing more than 60% of sales, and the turnover efficiency is also at the forefront of the industry.
It seems that the combination of "capital + strong founding team" is very competitive, and there is no incompatibility at all.
However, what needs to be viewed rationally is that at the operational level, the gradual cooling of the opening boom is adding uncertainty to the prospect of fresh snacks.
Take the first store in Shanghai as an example, after consumers' novelty for the new species fades, there is no longer a queue in the snack area. Moreover, not only Jinlimen, if you have visited the new stores of players such as Jiduquan, Xueji Fried Nuts, and Yili, you may have the same feeling.
The reason for the fading popularity is not difficult to understand.
On the one hand, fresh snacks lag behind ordinary snacks in accessibility and cost performance.
Because bulk snack stores, supermarkets, online snack channels, and bakeries are everywhere, you can buy regular snacks at any time.
However, fresh snack stores like Jinlimen are mostly located in shopping malls, requiring a special trip; in addition, some short-preservation products have inherent constraints, and you cannot hoard a large amount at one time, which is easy to expire if you buy too much, naturally limiting the purchase frequency.
For most people, snacks are something to satisfy cravings casually. After trying them for novelty, there seems to be no need to specially go to the shopping mall to consume relatively expensive fresh snacks.
On the other hand, the core selling point of "freshness" itself has a certain expectation gap.
Originally, when some people hear about fresh snacks, they will naturally focus on the word "fresh", and the brand does use 15-day short-preservation hit products to shape the impression of freshness in the whole store (short-preservation SKUs account for about 46.1%).
But after all, more than half of the SKUs on the shelves are still long-preservation snacks. Even for short-preservation products, many are products of central kitchens, not the freshly baked and freshly made on the same day state that consumers imagine.
In general, on the demand side, when the check-in popularity fades, people find that the freshness brought by the premium can be obtained from other places, the motivation to queue up will most likely disappear, and the passenger flow will return to normal.
Therefore, the real point that fresh snacks need to pay attention to is whether this business model can support the continuous expansion of the enterprise after the traffic and popularity pass in the next few years and consumers return to normalized consumption.
Popularity returns to normal, where is the way out for fresh snacks
After consumption returns to normalization, fresh snacks will mainly face two pressures:
First, the current offline business format is different from the state before fresh snacks "emerge".
New-era supermarkets such as Freshippo, Sam's Club, and 7FRESH have made freshly made short-preservation products a standard configuration, which is an invisible diversion of fresh snack users.
Friends who often visit these supermarkets will feel that in the supermarket's traffic line, as soon as you enter the store, you can see a complete bakery stall, then go inside to the fresh brine cooked food area, and in the middle are boxed short-preservation desserts, which also focus on freshly baked and sold on the same day, and their product structure highly overlaps with the short-preservation products of fresh snacks.
More critically, they themselves have stable community passenger flow and mature self-owned supply chain, and do not need to bear the cost of an entire independent store just to sell short-preservation snacks.
Moreover, now hit products of fresh snack stores such as melon seeds, buckwheat chips, meat floss rolls, and Swiss rolls have been quietly put on the shelves in these supermarkets.
For consumers, they can buy similar short-preservation baked goods and braised food when they visit the supermarket on the way, with more category choices and often more friendly prices. Coupled with Freshippo's free membership delivery system, the motivation to specially go to the fresh snack store in the shopping mall for check-in will naturally weaken.
To put it bluntly, the "freshly made" selling point that made fresh snacks stand out will gradually no longer be an exclusive label in the future, and the differentiation will be continuously diluted.
Second, the high operating cost.
Most of these stores are located on the B1 floor of core shopping malls, and the rent generally accounts for 16%-17% of revenue; at the same time, short-preservation categories require more employees to be responsible for sub-packaging, shelf life inspection, and restocking at different time periods, and a store of about 300 ㎡ often requires more than 20 employees.
Short-preservation loss is also a major rigid expenditure. The average industry loss rate is 8%-15%, which is several times that of bulk snacks. Once the passenger flow drops and the stocking forecast deviates, the unsold fresh brine and baked desserts on the same day can only be written off directly, which will directly erode the gross profit.
Of course, fresh snacks are not "soft persimmons". They can gain a good reputation even without expanding out of Hunan in the past two years, which naturally has its own moat.
The most core point among them is the regional short-preservation supply chain system.
Because short-preservation products are restricted by cold chain timeliness, the economic distribution radius is usually within 300 kilometers. This requires brands to build their own central factories and supporting cold chain warehouses, open stores densely around the production base, rely on store density to spread production and logistics costs, and at the same time compress the transit time of goods to control losses.
This system cannot be built quickly just by investing money. Production line debugging and distribution network construction both require a cycle. Once the scale is formed, the possibility of competitors catching up will be reduced.
If you don't believe it, look at Mixue Bingcheng. Up to now, no new tea drink enterprise can catch up with Mixue Bingcheng's supply chain system to achieve the same or even lower cost than it.
To put it bluntly, the moat of fresh snacks has many similarities with the business models of new tea drink enterprises such as Luckin Coffee and Mixue Bingcheng, all of which need to make great efforts in the supply chain.
In addition, the direct sales mode and refined operation of leading brands such as Jinlimen and Jiduquan can also form a certain moat in the field of chain retail.
For example, Anta's direct sales vs Li-Ning's distribution, Luckin Coffee's direct sales vs Cotti Coffee's franchising, Tesla's direct sales vs traditional car companies, those who adopt direct sales mode eventually outperform those who delegate power to distributors and franchisees.
With the successful precedents of the "predecessors", these are all moats that leading brands in the industry such as Jinlimen and Jiduquan can dig deep into.
Therefore, the future of fresh snacks will most likely be an era where all kinds of players have their own shares and shine together.
This is undoubtedly a great good thing for consumers.
It is also hoped that leading brands in the track such as Jinlimen will truly implement the commitment of "freshness" into the details of product quality and consumer experience, so that the traffic brought by the opening boom can be precipitated into long-term repurchasing retained users.
It is also hoped that all practitioners can keep their original aspiration of quality, move forward steadily with the help of capital, neither fail to live up to the market popularity nor underestimate the test of long-term operation, and finally give birth to national snack brands that can go through cycles, continuously bringing fresh, safe and delicious choices to consumers.
Disclaimer: The content related to listed companies in this article is the author's personal analysis and judgment based on the information publicly disclosed by listed companies in accordance with their legal obligations (including but not limited to temporary announcements, regular reports and official interactive platforms, etc.), but the author does not guarantee the completeness and timeliness of the information and materials; the information or opinions in the article do not constitute any investment or other business suggestions, and Caiguan Erjie will not bear any responsibility for any actions taken as a result of adopting this article.
| Author's note: Personal views are for reference only, images are from the network, if there is any infringement, please contact us to delete
This article is from the WeChat official account "Caiguan Erjie", author: Erjie, authorized to be released by 36Kr.