Copyright, Traffic and AI: A New Battle Dawns for Online Music Platforms
Music platforms have never had such an abundant supply of new songs as they do today, yet the next music star capable of continuously generating commercial value remains hard to find.
On November 17, Tencent Music released its financial report for the third quarter of 2026, posting revenue of 8.941 billion yuan, a year-on-year increase of 5.6%, which fell below the market consensus expectation.
Relying on premium memberships, concerts and artist peripherals, this online music giant is further tapping into the commercial value of mature IPs, but user activity for its core products remains under pressure.
The business of stock IPs is getting deeper, and the competition rules for new music are also changing.
In August this year, Li Lingling, Senior Director of Music Library Copyright at Tencent Music, disclosed that the platform's average daily number of newly added songs has reached about 160,000, of which AI songs account for about 45%. In contrast, the number of newly added songs per day in the same period last year was less than 100,000.
AI has greatly lowered the threshold for song production, and created more possibilities for the emergence of new musicians and virtual artists.
When massive works flood into the market, the competition between music platforms is extending from copyright reserve and song distribution to the absorption of new supplies and the cultivation and operation of next-generation IPs.
The ability to make new works popular and convert short-term popularity into long-term revenue is becoming the new focus of competition.
I
Embracing New Supplies
Faced with this supply-side change, Tencent Music, NetEase Cloud Music and Qishui Music have all chosen not to reject it.
Over the past year, the moves of the three platforms have shown a similar general direction: strengthening content governance, while developing AI creation tools, distribution services and incentive mechanisms.
However, due to their different commercial foundations, the problems they prioritize solving also vary.
For Tencent Music, which is known for its mature copyright resources, the first priority is to coordinate the relationship between new AI supplies and existing copyright interests.
In March this year, the management of Tencent Music proposed revenue rules that distinguish different types of works: songs produced with AI assistance and sung by real artists can follow the traditional copyright sharing system;
For works that fully use AI virtual vocals, other models such as UGC incentives will be explored, and they will not be included in the same copyright sharing system for real human singing works.
NetEase Cloud Music also implements classified management for AI works, and distinguishes music supplies of different natures through content labeling, special incentives and review mechanisms.
For NetEase Cloud Music, which is known for its independent musicians and community culture, AI not only provides an opportunity to expand original supplies, but also may weaken its original differentiated advantages.
In the past, NetEase Cloud relied on the independent musician ecosystem and user community to establish its own market space outside the head copyright competition. However, when AI generally lowers the threshold for song production, the supply of original content itself may no longer be scarce.
NetEase Cloud has therefore further tried to integrate AI into its existing community.
In June this year, it upgraded its AI music creation and distribution tool "NetEase Tianyin", connecting song creation with one-click distribution, and using the "Music Comment Inspiration" function to allow ordinary listeners to participate in music production.
These moves are not only aimed at increasing the number of songs, but also hope to strengthen the connection between content production and community consumption.
As the party with the lightest copyright assets, Qishui Music has fewer potential conflicts of interest with new AI supplies, so it is more motivated to expand its music library through this.
However, compared with the other two platforms, Qishui Music under the free model has a lower per-user value, and expanding the music library is far from the end. The top priority is to improve the overall commercialization efficiency — that is, after using Douyin to convert new songs into listening volume, further convert the huge traffic into continuous revenue through distribution, authorization and diversified commercial services.
Based on this logic, Qishui Music has adopted a more open attitude towards new AI supplies.
In March this year, Qishui Music and Douyin clearly stated at the industry conference that they treat AI-assisted songs equally: as long as they meet the copyright and content quality standards and can be recognized by the market, they will also enjoy normal distribution and revenue sharing.
AI has been embedded in its original support and distribution system.
ByteDance's "Miaoxiang" connects the entire link from AI creation to distribution and settlement on the Open Music Platform; Douyin uses AI to assist in matching promotion influencers, producing MVs and secondary creative content, reducing the comprehensive cost of new songs from production to breaking through the circle.
A series of moves show that Qishui Music is not satisfied with distributing massive AI works through algorithms, but tries to use the combination of "tools + traffic + distribution" to increase the probability of monetization of new songs, and then attract more creators to join in.
In the final analysis, AI has greatly lowered the threshold for music production, but has not equally reduced the difficulty of obtaining traffic and realizing monetization.
When all three platforms can obtain massive new works, the focus of competition further shifts to: who can discover and cultivate content with commercial value, and how much return can be obtained from it.
II
Reuse and Reproduction of IPs
The rise of AI short dramas reveals a trend after the surge in content supply: works are easier to produce, but high-quality IPs that can continuously attract users and create commercial value are still scarce.
This puts two tasks in front of music platforms: to extend the commercial life cycle of mature IPs as much as possible, and to cultivate the next generation of artists from massive new works.
For example, Tencent Music is further tapping into the commercial value of mature IPs along its existing copyright advantages.
In the third quarter of this year, the number of SVIP paying users and monthly ARPPU of the company continued to grow, and the revenue from marketing and consumer services including advertising, performances and artist peripherals reached 2.7 billion yuan, a year-on-year increase of 12.1%.
Around the stock head artists, Tencent Music is extending the commercial chain from song playback to performances, peripherals and fan services.
For the 20th anniversary of BIGBANG's debut, the platform combined online promotion with offline themed exhibitions in 19 cities across the country, driving the playback of the classic music library and peripheral sales; for strategic artists such as Wang Sulong, it further expanded performances, physical albums and peripheral consumption.
However, extending the commercial chain of IP also means that the platform needs to bear more operating costs.
In addition, deep cultivation of stock IPs cannot replace the competition for new users and new works.
Third-party data cited by Nomura Securities shows that in September this year, the daily active users of QQ Music, Kugou Music and Kuwo Music decreased by 6%, 16% and 11% year-on-year respectively, NetEase Cloud Music increased slightly by 2%, and Qishui Music increased by 54%.
Facing the competition of free music, Tencent Music quietly launched the independent app "Free Music" on the Huawei AppGallery in August this year, turning listening to songs into a "song-swiping" stream similar to short video swiping, trying to retain the light, price-sensitive users lost from Kugou.
On the other hand, Tencent Music has strengthened its cooperation with WeChat Channels: Users can jump from Channels to QQ Music and Kugou Music. Tencent Music has also become the main operator of the music category on Channels, expanding music promotion and user diversion through this.
Behind this is not only the competition for user scale, but also the competition for the entrance of music discovery and new artist cultivation.
AI has greatly lowered the threshold for music creation, but from a single song to a mature artist IP, work promotion, fan operation and commercial development are still required. Having AI creation tools alone does not mean having complete star-making capabilities.
Various platforms have begun to try different cultivation paths.
"Datouzhen Official", an AI singer created by Kugou Music under Tencent Music, became popular last year with its smoky voice covers, and had more than 26 million monthly listeners earlier this year.
After that, Kugou launched the original song "Best Man" produced by a professional lyricist and composer team for it, and promoted it to appear on "2026 China AI Ceremony" on CCTV.
NetEase Cloud focuses more on discovering new artists from the creator community.
In June this year, its second million-yuan prize AI music creation competition attracted more than 20,000 creators, receiving more than 160,000 submissions including songs, music comments and MVs. The champion Lil Wukong won a prize of 300,000 yuan.
However, Lil Wukong later also appeared in the representative project of Douyin's "AI New Voice Plan 2.0".
"Man Roaming Conference Room", who served as the judge of the first competition and became popular with the "Journey to the West" themed AI songs, also gained early attention mainly through Douyin and Bilibili, and then distributed the songs to NetEase Cloud Music.
NetEase Cloud Music can gather and screen original musicians, but it lacks its own short video traffic entrance of the same scale as Douyin and Channels. When there are more and more AI works, how to help musicians break through the community circle has become a more prominent competitive problem for it.
With the development of video generation technology, short dramas and virtual artists have also begun to become important supply sources for new music.
The AI short drama "NOVA Star" in ByteDance's ecosystem shows another star-making path.
This short drama revolves around the virtual girl group FourOne, integrating the members' debut, song production and fan operation into the same content system. The four members each have their own songs, MVs and Douyin accounts, and continuously interact with the audience.
By the end of October, the cumulative playback volume of the short drama exceeded 130 million times, the main account gained about 600,000 new fans in two months, and the title song "Hao" got more than 100,000 likes on Qishui Music, and brand commercial cooperation has begun to emerge.
Short dramas, music and virtual artists are beginning to form together in the same content production system.
But the advantage of communication does not mean mastering IP revenue. The character operation and commercial cooperation of "NOVA Star" are mainly promoted by the creator team. Whether Qishui Music can further participate in long-term copyright and IP operation still needs subsequent verification.
The capabilities of the three platforms thus form differences: Tencent Music has a mature professional production and IP operation system, and is reinforcing its communication entrance; NetEase Cloud is good at discovering original musicians, but lacks external traffic support relatively; Qishui Music, relying on Douyin, participated in the formation of new IPs earlier.
AI has lowered the threshold for music production, but it has not made it easier for stars to be operated for a long time.
The competition among music platforms is extending from competing for song supply to who can convert the popularity of works into lasting fan relationships and commercial value.
This article is from the WeChat official account "All-Weather Tech" (ID: iawtmt), written by Liu Yichen, authorized for release by 36Kr.