More than 80% of such funds have recorded positive returns since their establishment, with the highest return exceeding 45%. The performance of recently launched funds is generally unsatisfactory, and some products have suffered a loss of nearly 20% in more than 5 months.
In November 2022, the personal pension system was first implemented in several pilot cities, and then gradually entered the full implementation stage. Over the past four years, the number of listed Y-share personal pension funds has reached 351. As of November 13, 2026, more than 80% of Y-share products have recorded positive returns since their inception.
Affected by market fluctuations in the second half of this year, Y-share funds established within this year generally have poor returns. Surveyed institutions believe that compared with assets such as wealth management products and insurance, public-offering Y-shares have a wider space for asset allocation, can invest in multiple assets including equity and fixed income, and have stronger long-term return flexibility.
Over 80% of Products Have Positive Returns Since Inception
At present, there are 351 Y-share personal pension fund products in the entire market, covering types such as pension target date FOFs, pension target risk FOFs, "fixed income +" products, index funds and index enhancement funds. Wind data shows that as of the end of the third quarter of 2026, the total scale of Y-share personal pension funds is about 27.665 billion RMB.
Guotai Fund analyzed to Zhongxin Jingwei that in terms of the number of holders, the number of Y-share holder households increased from 387,600 at the end of 2022 to 2.9739 million at the end of the second quarter of 2026. More and more ordinary investors have actively embraced the long-term investment concept of pension, and regard Y-shares as an allocation tool for the cross-cycle accumulation of their own pension wealth.
In terms of product returns, Wind data shows that as of November 13, 2026, among the 351 Y-share products, 284 have recorded positive returns since their inception, accounting for about 80.91%.
Zhongxin Jingwei's sorting shows that the Y-share personal pension funds with top returns generally have an establishment duration of 2 years or more.
There are 14 products with returns exceeding 30% since their inception. Among them, the three products, E Fund Pension Target Date 2055 5-Year Holding Y, E Fund Huiyu Active Pension Target 5-Year Holding Y, and E Fund Pension Target Date 2050 5-Year Holding Y, have the highest returns, reaching about 45.51%, 42.42% and 40.48% respectively.
From the perspective of relatively short-term indicators, the number of Y-share personal pension funds with positive returns in the past year has decreased significantly. Wind data shows that as of November 13, 2026, among the Y-share funds with performance data, only 38 have recorded positive returns in the past year.
Returns of Newly Established Funds This Year Rank at the Bottom
Affected by the market adjustment in the second half of 2026, the returns of newly established Y-share personal pension fund products this year are generally unsatisfactory.
Huitianfu Pension 2060 5-Year Holding Y, established on May 29 this year, is a FOF product (note: fund of funds, which mainly invests in publicly offered funds that have been issued). According to its quarterly report, this fund has invested in multiple publicly offered funds with heavy positions in the technology sector. With the rapid decline of the AI sector since the second half of this year, the net value of the product has also dropped significantly.
As of November 13, the return of Huitianfu Pension 2060 5-Year Holding Y since its inception is about -18.57%, ranking at the bottom of all Y-share funds. Li Biao, the fund manager of this product, said that the portfolio was adjusted opportunistically in the third quarter, appropriately reducing positions in the technology sector and slightly increasing defensive industries and themes. However, the adjustment range was not large enough, so the portfolio was greatly impacted in the market decline. At the current point in time, he is relatively optimistic about the future market.
Multiple Y-share funds newly established this year that track the broad market index have poor returns. As of November 13, the returns of Guotai CSI A500 ETF Linked Y, Huitianfu CSI 300 Fundamental Enhancement Y, Furong CSI 300 Enhancement Y, Haifutong CSI 300 Index Enhancement Y, and Invesco Great Wall CSI 300 Enhancement Y since their inception are about -15.77%, -15.70%, -15.70%, -15.61% and -15.50% respectively.
How Do Investors Choose Y-Shares?
Comparing with categories such as bank wealth management products, savings deposits, and commercial endowment insurance, Guotai Fund believes that bank savings and wealth management products are relatively stable with low volatility, while commercial endowment insurance focuses on locked-in withdrawal and risk protection.
Guotai Fund stated that the advantages of public-offering Y-shares lie in the following aspects: First, they have a wider asset allocation space, can invest in multiple assets such as equity and fixed income, and have stronger long-term return flexibility. Second, the pension target mechanism is clear: target date products come with a glide path that automatically reduces equity exposure as the investor ages, adapting to the pension life cycle; target risk products maintain a fixed risk center, making it convenient for investors to independently choose long-term positions that match their own risk preferences. The two types of products jointly meet the pension planning needs of different residents. Third, they feature high transparency, fair valuation, special preferential fee rates, and standardized disclosure of subscription, redemption and positions. Fourth, the public offering investment and research system is mature, with rich experience in long-term capital management, which is suitable for taking the value-added position in the portfolio.
At present, Y-share funds can be roughly divided into three categories: FOFs, "fixed income +" products, and index or index enhancement products. Regarding the characteristics of pension FOF funds, Guotai Fund said that they can give full play to the advantages of multi-asset and multi-strategy diversification, dynamically adjust the exposure of broad categories of assets based on the cost-effectiveness of stocks and bonds, build the portfolio's bottom position with fixed income assets, appropriately enhance returns through balanced and selected equity instruments, and hedge volatility by allocating low-correlation assets, so as to adapt to the goals of long-term, stable and controllable drawdown of pension funds.
Regarding "fixed income +" products, Guotai Fund said that they can anchor the risk-return boundary, adhere to the idea of taking bonds as the base and prudently enhancing returns through equity investments. On the bond side, they focus on medium and high-grade credit bonds, capture coupon income, and flexibly adjust duration to cope with interest rate changes. On the equity side, they maintain diversification, strictly control positions, give priority to targets with high dividend yield and sufficient safety margin, do not bet on a single track, and steadily increase returns on the premise of controlling drawdowns.
The views in this article are for reference only and do not constitute investment advice. Investment involves risks, and caution is advised when entering the market.
This article is from the WeChat Official Account "Zhongxin Jingwei" (ID: jwview), written by Xue Yufei, and published with authorization from 36Kr.