Draft Revision of the Tax Collection and Administration Law Seeks Public Opinions: Late Payment Surcharge is Capped at Double the Amount of the Tax Payable, and Internet Platform Enterprises Are Brought into the Scope of Supervision
On November 6, the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Administration of Tax Collection (Revised Draft) (hereinafter referred to as the "Revised Draft") was publicly released for public comments. The Revised Draft consists of 100 articles in 6 chapters, adding 13 new articles, deleting 7 articles, and revising 75 articles compared with the current Law on the Administration of Tax Collection.
The current Law on the Administration of Tax Collection was promulgated in 1992 and fully revised in 2001. It has been implemented for more than 20 years, and the problems that are increasingly incompatible with the current tax collection and payment practice have become prominent.
On the one hand, the Revised Draft sets a two-fold cap on the late payment surcharge for tax arrears, and adds circumstances where the surcharge is exempted from being levied; at the same time, it cancels the provision requiring tax settlement before administrative reconsideration, no longer taking full payment of tax arrears or provision of guarantee as the prerequisite for taxpayers to file administrative reconsideration, so as to better guarantee taxpayers' right to exercise administrative relief. On the other hand, the Revised Draft further clarifies the requirements for tax authorities to perform their duties in accordance with the law, and improves the provisions on tax recovery measures and relevant legal liabilities.
In addition, the Revised Draft fully adapts to the new situation of the development of the digital economy, and clarifies that internet platform enterprises shall handle tax-related matters such as tax declaration for relevant operators and employees on the platform in accordance with relevant regulations.
Ye Yongqing, partner of Anli Partners, told Economic Observer that out of the consideration of stabilizing the tax collection and administration order and proceeding step by step, the Revised Draft did not choose "major revision" in combination with the current status of tax collection and administration, and generally maintained the macro structure and main provisions of the current law. Although many disputes have not been completely resolved, the Revised Draft has made efforts to respond to a number of key issues to be solved urgently in practice, and has made revisions in both protecting taxpayers' rights and improving tax collection and administration capabilities. While responding to current development and practical needs, it has also made positive efforts to reflect the concept of balance of rights between the tax collection authority and taxpayers, which is exactly the core essence of the Law on the Administration of Tax Collection as a tax procedural law.
Tax Administration of the Platform Economy
The Third Plenary Session of the 20th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China clearly put forward reform tasks such as "promoting the innovative development of the platform economy, improving the regular supervision system for the platform economy" and "studying the tax system adapted to new business forms".
In 2025, the Provisions on the Submission of Tax-related Information by Internet Platform Enterprises and supporting announcements were issued successively, providing institutional support and practical guidance for promoting the standardized and healthy development of the platform economy.
The newly added Article 29 of this Revised Draft stipulates that internet platform enterprises shall submit tax-related information such as identity information and income information of operators and employees on the platform to tax authorities in accordance with the law. Internet platform enterprises shall handle tax-related matters such as tax declaration for operators and employees on the platform in accordance with relevant state regulations.
The newly added Article 66 requires that where an internet platform enterprise fails to submit tax-related information in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 1 of Article 29 of this Law, the tax authority shall order it to make corrections within a time limit; if it fails to make corrections after the expiration of the time limit, it shall be fined not less than 20,000 yuan but not more than 100,000 yuan; if the circumstances are serious, it shall be fined not less than 100,000 yuan but not more than 500,000 yuan; if the circumstances are particularly serious, it shall be fined not less than 500,000 yuan but not more than 2 million yuan; if the circumstances are serious or particularly serious, the tax authority may order it to suspend relevant businesses or suspend business for rectification. Where an internet platform enterprise fails to handle tax-related matters such as tax declaration for operators and employees on the platform in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 2 of Article 29 of this Law, the tax authority shall order it to make corrections within a time limit; if it fails to make corrections after the expiration of the time limit, the internet platform enterprise shall be fined not less than 50% but not more than 3 times the amount of unpaid or underpaid tax by the operators and employees on the platform.
Ye Yongqing told Economic Observer that tax collection and administration is based on information acquisition, and when the current administration law was formulated, the platform economy had not yet emerged, so legislators could not foresee the transaction structure of the platform economy, and the acquisition of third-party information had long been promoted relying on departmental rules and individual cases. This revision writes the platform information submission and agency declaration into the law, requiring platforms to submit tax-related information of operators and employees, and assist in handling declaration matters, which fully reflects the insight and judgment of the development trend of tax collection and administration in the digital era.
Ye Yongqing said that in the era of digital economy, transactions have shifted from offline to the cloud, and the traditional administration model can hardly cover scattered and high-frequency online activities. As a hub connecting both ends of supply and demand, platforms naturally master the capital flow and information flow. Making them assume appropriate tax assistance obligations is not only an internationally accepted practice, but also an inevitable choice for "tax governance based on data". Elevating the information disclosure requirements previously clarified in the form of State Council regulations and departmental rules to law, so as to connect with the Provisions on the Submission of Tax-related Information by Internet Platform Enterprises of 2025, not only solves the problem of legal basis, but also fully responds to the basic problem of information asymmetry between the two parties of tax collection and payment under the platform economy, realizing the goal of platform tax governance moving from the policy level to regularization and rule of law.
The Revised Draft also improves the tax-related information sharing mechanism (Article 6, Paragraph 2 of Article 18), clarifies that information collected by tax authorities in accordance with tax treaties and agreements can be used as the basis for law enforcement (Paragraph 2 of Article 98), and writes the major asset disposal reporting system for taxpayers with unpaid taxes, which was previously established by rules, into the law (Article 51), laying a certain foundation for the next step to use the results of overseas information exchange to carry out overseas income recovery law enforcement, so that the information acquisition of tax authorities and the compliance expectation of taxpayers obtain the same stability.
"The platform information submission work has been implemented and operated in accordance with the provisions of the State Council before. This revision complements the superior legal basis, eliminates the doubts at the legality level, and also conforms to the changes of the times to improve tax governance under the "Internet + Digitalization" environment," Ye Yongqing said.
Two-fold Cap on Late Payment Surcharge
The late payment surcharge system is an important rule in tax collection, and it is also a system with many disputes in the field of tax law enforcement and judicature in recent years. The core disputes focus on two points: whether the late payment surcharge for tax arrears can exceed the principal, and whether the daily additional standard of 0.05% is too high.
Article 32 of the current Law on the Administration of Tax Collection stipulates: "Where a taxpayer fails to pay tax within the prescribed time limit, and a withholding agent fails to remit tax within the prescribed time limit, the tax authority shall, in addition to ordering the payment within a time limit, levy a late payment surcharge at a rate of 0.05% per day on the amount of tax in arrears, counting from the date the tax is overdue."
Xu Yina, lawyer of Beijing Hengdu (Guangzhou) Law Firm, told Economic Observer that the late payment surcharge levied at 0.05% per day on the amount of tax in arrears is converted to an annualized rate of 18.25%, which far exceeds the 4 times LPR (Loan Prime Rate), the upper limit of judicial protection for private lending interest rates, with obvious punitive nature; however, this late payment surcharge is not constrained by the one-fold cap rule of the Law of the People's Republic of China on Administrative Compulsion (hereinafter referred to as the "Administrative Compulsion Law"), and also conflicts with the principle of no double jeopardy for one act - tax evasion itself is also subject to a fine of 0.5 to 5 times.
Article 45 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on Administrative Compulsion promulgated in 2011 stipulates: Where the parties concerned fail to perform the administrative decision of monetary payment obligation made by the administrative organ in accordance with the law, the administrative organ may impose a fine or late payment surcharge in accordance with the law. The amount of the additional fine or late payment surcharge shall not exceed the amount of the monetary payment obligation.
These disputes have been reflected to a certain extent in this revision.
In March 2025, in the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Administration of Tax Collection (Revised Draft for Comments) disclosed by the State Taxation Administration and the Ministry of Finance, the "late payment surcharge" in the Law on the Administration of Tax Collection was once modified to "tax late payment fee".
This Revised Draft renames the "late payment surcharge" as "tax late payment surcharge", clarifies that the tax late payment surcharge shall not exceed twice the principal amount of tax, and adds a number of circumstances where the tax late payment surcharge is exempted from being levied.
In Ye Yongqing's view, the Revised Draft abides by the statutory taxation principle, does not adopt the expression of "late payment fee", and avoids the path of bypassing the Administrative Compulsion Law through text adjustment. On the basis of clarifying the nature of the tax late payment surcharge, the draft continues to use the concept of late payment surcharge, maintains the unity of legal terms, and at the same time sets an upper limit for late payment surcharge, striving to balance the interests of all parties in the system design. Although the additional rate is still on the high side, and the response to the reasonable circumstances of late payment surcharge reduction and exemption in practice is still insufficient, this revision is still an important progress, which is the maintenance and implementation of the statutory taxation principle.
Xu Yina believes that although this revision of the administration law tries to bring the tax late payment surcharge closer to the qualitative nature of "compensatory interest", at the level of enterprise income tax, this expenditure is still classified as punitive expenditure and shall not be deducted before tax in accordance with the law.
From the perspective of international practice, it is a relatively common arrangement to set a separate incidental burden for overdue tax payment and clarify its legal attribute. For example, the U.S. Internal Revenue Code levies additional payments on underpaid tax, which is essentially defined as interest; the UK adopts the expression of "late payment interest"; the "delinquency tax" in the Japanese National Tax General Law is positioned as an incidental tax with the attribute of interest.
Professor Shi Zhengwen from China University of Political Science and Law believes that the tax late payment surcharge is not the same concept as the late payment surcharge under the Administrative Compulsion Law. The tax late payment surcharge is automatically levied in accordance with the law when the taxpayer fails to pay tax overdue. On the one hand, it compensates for the loss of the state's tax being occupied, with certain interest attributes; on the other hand, it plays a role in restricting and urging taxpayers to pay tax on schedule, with a disciplinary color. The late payment surcharge in the Administrative Compulsion Law is aimed at the parties refusing to perform the effective monetary payment decision, which generally needs to be made a decision and urged before being levied, with the disciplinary function as the main part. The two are different in nature, starting mode and discretionary rules, so it is not appropriate to directly apply the relevant provisions of the Administrative Compulsion Law on the additional procedure and "the additional late payment surcharge shall not exceed the amount of the monetary payment obligation" to judge the tax late payment surcharge. The naming and qualitative determination of this revision also conforms to the consensus formed by the fiscal and taxation departments, legislative and judicial organs in recent years.
While setting a two-fold upper limit, this revision retains the provision of levying a late payment surcharge at 0.05% per day on the amount of tax in arrears.
Ye Yongqing believes that although additional payments are needed to make up for the capital occupation loss suffered by the state due to the delayed performance of tax claims, the annualized levy rate of 18.25% determines that the punitive attribute of late payment surcharge objectively exists, and its core role is still to urge tax arrears subjects to settle the tax as soon as possible with a higher cost.
A tax director of an institution said that the standard of 0.05% late payment surcharge per day is on the high side, and the burden is particularly prominent under the current environment of declining interest rates. He speculated that the standard of 0.05% was initially set to align with the benchmark interest rate at that time; now that the individual income tax threshold has been raised many times and the market interest rate continues to decline, even if the late payment surcharge retains the punitive attribute, it should be dynamically adjusted with the economic environment.
At the same time, the Revised Draft adds a number of new circumstances where the tax late payment surcharge is exempted, excluding some cases of underpaid tax caused by non-subjective faults of taxpayers, mainly including: those who are unable to pay tax on schedule due to force majeure and make up the payment in time after the obstacle is eliminated; those who need to re-pay tax due to reasons such as adjustment of storage location, tax category attribute and collection authority; taxpayers who voluntarily make up the tax that has exceeded the recovery period. "Under these circumstances, taxpayers have no subjective intention to delay tax payment, and some even actively cooperate. It is really unreasonable to levy late payment surcharge again," said the relevant person in charge of the State Taxation Administration. The newly added exemption provision is to collect the late payment surcharge that should be collected in accordance with the law, and resolutely not collect those that should not be collected, making the system more warm and more in line with the principle of fairness.
This article is from the WeChat Official Account "Economic Observer", author: Du Tao, published with authorization from 36Kr.